employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

New York Public Library

Is this your company?

Dream job that turned into a nightmare - Information Assistant New York Public Library Employee Review

3.0
11 Aug 2019
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great opportunity for creative people; talented staff; room for growth.

Cons

If you apply for a position in a branch of the New York Public Library, be aware that you can be transferred at a moment’s notice, and end up in a place where you may be unhappy, and at times scared. I wish I knew that could happen before I applied for a position at a branch in a quiet suburban setting. Within a week or two, I was telling friends that I found the perfect job. I chatted with patrons about good books. I led Crafternoon programs. I created many themed book displays, and posted lots of photos on social media. I was so content, so happy. Several months later, upper management told me I was to be immediately transferred to a different branch in a vastly different urban neighborhood. My position was going to an employee who needed to be transferred :for security reasons, and since I was the most recent hire, I could not protest. My first week in the new branch, I discovered that security guards were posted on every level. Black mold was growing in the supply closet, likely from the leaking roof. A couch infested with bedbugs was removed by being dragged – uncovered – through the main room and out the front door. A colleague discovered fleas. I arrived at work one morning to find a man urinating on the staff entrance door. A binder of banned patrons was several inches thick, and police were sometimes called to escort them out. One day, a patron started violently beating the copy machine and screaming; security led him out. Another time, a patron complained about strong body odor in the computer section; a guard just shrugged and told him there was nothing he could do. Some co-workers told me I would become hardened to the clientele and the conditions. I admire their spirit and strength, but many days I had a stress headache. One day, two guards stood on either side of me at the information desk because of concerns that an angry patron might pose a threat. Ironically, I had just completed a NYPL course on “conflict resolution” where I learned the proper stance to take when threatened, and received a handbook titled “Challenged by Mental Illness at Work.” I searched the web and learned that library staff around the country are increasingly faced with situations that can escalate at a moment’s notice. My stress reached a breaking point, and I gave notice. I’m certain that if I had remained at the branch where I applied and was hired, I would still be there today, happy and content. Although NYPL offers tremendous opportunity and great benefits, be prepared for where you may end up working.

Explore other reviews about New York Public Library

5.0
22 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Flexible schedule and overall fun work environment

Cons

I don’t have any cons

3.0
26 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

- Unparalleled work-life balance, especially for tech workers. - A very relaxed and friendly environment with no micromanagement. - Generous leave policies. - Most projects have very slow deadlines, so there’s no significant work pressure. - A laissez-faire work culture. - If you’re contemplating retirement, pursuing a master’s degree, or starting a side hustle, this is an excellent place to work.

Cons

- Compensation is significantly below market rate. - Toxic directors and senior leaders favor certain employees and encourage sycophancy. Sycophants are rewarded with benefits such as flexible work schedules and the ability to work remotely. - Promotion is contingent upon being a sycophant. - Directors and senior leaders often avoid the office altogether or have erratic schedules, such as arriving at 7 pm and leaving whenever they please, while simultaneously enforcing strict rules. - If you’re an ambitious individual seeking career growth, this is not the ideal place to be.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All