Pros
There are genuinely capable and generous people at Artsy, and many work hard in spite of the wider culture. Some relationships will outlast your time there.
Cons
Artsy's mission and its reality have drifted far apart. The company presents itself as a principled tech leader transforming the art world, but the product's actual impact is limited and its business model often extracts more value than it creates for most galleries. The push for office attendance is driven less by collaboration and more by a basic lack of trust in employees. In New York, leaders often make a point of occupying other corners or floors to avoid casual interaction. Leadership rarely owns its failures. Blame lands on individuals often for outcomes shaped by unclear direction or last-minute pivots they had no part in deciding. Knowing what you're actually supposed to be achieving, and for whom, is harder than it should be. HR operates more as an internal surveillance, gatekeeping and alliance-management function than a support one. Information shared in confidence has a way of reaching the wrong people, protection follows proximity to power not clear process or ability, and repeated reorgs disrupt teams before they find momentum. To get ahead here make sure you flatter upward, deflect blame onto others, and perform enthusiasm in Slack, in meetings, through every pivot, get ahead, including by throwing weight behind bad bets that others then have to absorb.